Earlier post “Process Critical Line” has presented a checklist of process critical line. During design phase, these process shall be checked in detail to minimize or avoid problem such as vibration, hammering, capacity reduction, cavitation, etc to occur. This post will further present good engineering practice for process critical line.
Gravity Flow
Any line subject to gravity flow e.g. drain, flare, vent, etc, low pocket shall be avoided. Liquid or solid accumulate in low pocket potentially result corrosion and blockage. Line should be sloped (and/or free draining) from sources to receiver.
Pump Suction
Line to pump suction should be designed to allow self floating as far as possible where lowest liquid level is above the pump highest point.
Recommended :
- Subscribe FREE - Chemical Engineering
- Tips on Succession in FREE Subscription
Gravity Flow
Any line subject to gravity flow e.g. drain, flare, vent, etc, low pocket shall be avoided. Liquid or solid accumulate in low pocket potentially result corrosion and blockage. Line should be sloped (and/or free draining) from sources to receiver.
Pump Suction
Line to pump suction should be designed to allow self floating as far as possible where lowest liquid level is above the pump highest point.
Recommended :
- Subscribe FREE - Chemical Engineering
- Tips on Succession in FREE Subscription
Ensure minimum submergence of tank to avoid potential vapor being sucked in to pump suction line due to vortex. If positive submergence is not achievable, installation of vortex breaker is another option. Read more in “Vortex Breaker to Avoid Vapor Entrainment”.
Any high pocket shall be avoided and provision of eccentric reducer at the pump suction to avoid potentially vapor lock prior to pump start-up.
Ensure NPSHa is always higher than NPSHr with a positive margin e.g. 1m for entire operation range (turndown to design capacity) and operation conditions (highest operating temperature). There are 17 Ways to Reduce Likelihood of Pump Cavitation.
Minimize suction length and fitting as much as possible to minimize potential of pump cavitation.
Compressor Suction
Compressor suction knock out drum (KOD) may be equipped with mist eliminator e.g. wiremesh to promote droplet coalescing and separation.
KOD vapor exit nozzle should be designed large enough to minimize exit momentum (rho V2 less than 6000 Pa) in order to minimize reentrainment of coalesced liquid droplet into vapor.
Compressor in general can tolerate small amount of liquid. If absolute no liquid is allowed enter compressor as imposed by compressor manufacturer, one may consider provision of insulation to minimize ambient and JT cooling and heat tracing to compensate heat loss due to above mentioned cooling.
Absolute no low pocket shall present in the compressor suction line as low pocket can accumulate liquid and slug of liquid can cause severe damage to compressor.
May consider a compressor suction strainer for start-up and commissioning. As compressor is sensitive to suction line pressure drop, any additional fitting and device at compressor suction can lead to capacity reduction, installation of suction strainer shall be analyzed in detail during design phase.
Flashing / Two phase Gas-Liquid Flow
Slugging and plugging flow in vertical and horizontal potentially results significant vibration to piping. During process design phase, slugging and plugging flow shall be avoided for entire operating range (turndown to design capacity) and operating conditions.
May consider provision of vapor liquid separation and run separator separate header for vapor and liquid line if slugging / plugging flow is unavoidable. For steam header, provide sufficient steam traps to drain-off condensate and minimize potential of slugging flow.
Extra and strengthen support may be provided to avoid severe vibration and failure on pipe crack.
Liquid-Liquid Coalescer
Vapor generation in liquid-liquid coalescer may accumulate and result under-performed liquid-liquid separation. May consider to provide sufficient static head to suppress vapor generation in liquid-liquid coalescer. It is always recommended to provide a vapor equalization line back to separator to release any vapor form in liquid-liquid coalescer.
Low Pressure Line
Minimizing pressure drop in low pressure line is the key factor to ensure proper performance of system. Minimize line length, fittings, elbow, etc and use of smooth surface pipe e.g. stainless steel may be considered.
Potential Surge Line
Steam supply line experience heat loss and condensation due to partially damaged insulation and extreme low ambient temperature. Flashing condensate with steam return to collection header mix with cold condensate. Both condition would results sudden steam collapse and lead to implosion. Steam implosion would generate severe movement of condensate in the collection header and severe vibration of header. Therefore proper maintenance of insulation is extremely important in keep steam line from transient surge. Besides, provide sufficient steam trap to eliminate condensate from steam line.
Long pipeline transferring incompressible fluid e.g. LNG rundown line, produce water injection line, etc potentially experience transient surge (water hammer) in the event of closure of shutdown valve. Transient surge analysis shall be conducted during design phase to ensure surge is avoided. Slower closure of shutdown valve is one of the key component in minimizing surge in long pipe line. Non-slam check valve on the pump discharge may also assist in minimizing surge in long pipeline with pump. Surge suppression system may be considered in the event surge is unavoidable. One shall take note that provision of pressure relief valve may not help to eliminating surge due to slow response time of PRV.
Pressure Relief Valve Inlet & Outlet
May consider discussion and recommendation in :
Any high pocket shall be avoided and provision of eccentric reducer at the pump suction to avoid potentially vapor lock prior to pump start-up.
Ensure NPSHa is always higher than NPSHr with a positive margin e.g. 1m for entire operation range (turndown to design capacity) and operation conditions (highest operating temperature). There are 17 Ways to Reduce Likelihood of Pump Cavitation.
Minimize suction length and fitting as much as possible to minimize potential of pump cavitation.
Compressor Suction
Compressor suction knock out drum (KOD) may be equipped with mist eliminator e.g. wiremesh to promote droplet coalescing and separation.
KOD vapor exit nozzle should be designed large enough to minimize exit momentum (rho V2 less than 6000 Pa) in order to minimize reentrainment of coalesced liquid droplet into vapor.
Compressor in general can tolerate small amount of liquid. If absolute no liquid is allowed enter compressor as imposed by compressor manufacturer, one may consider provision of insulation to minimize ambient and JT cooling and heat tracing to compensate heat loss due to above mentioned cooling.
Absolute no low pocket shall present in the compressor suction line as low pocket can accumulate liquid and slug of liquid can cause severe damage to compressor.
May consider a compressor suction strainer for start-up and commissioning. As compressor is sensitive to suction line pressure drop, any additional fitting and device at compressor suction can lead to capacity reduction, installation of suction strainer shall be analyzed in detail during design phase.
Flashing / Two phase Gas-Liquid Flow
Slugging and plugging flow in vertical and horizontal potentially results significant vibration to piping. During process design phase, slugging and plugging flow shall be avoided for entire operating range (turndown to design capacity) and operating conditions.
May consider provision of vapor liquid separation and run separator separate header for vapor and liquid line if slugging / plugging flow is unavoidable. For steam header, provide sufficient steam traps to drain-off condensate and minimize potential of slugging flow.
Extra and strengthen support may be provided to avoid severe vibration and failure on pipe crack.
Liquid-Liquid Coalescer
Vapor generation in liquid-liquid coalescer may accumulate and result under-performed liquid-liquid separation. May consider to provide sufficient static head to suppress vapor generation in liquid-liquid coalescer. It is always recommended to provide a vapor equalization line back to separator to release any vapor form in liquid-liquid coalescer.
Low Pressure Line
Minimizing pressure drop in low pressure line is the key factor to ensure proper performance of system. Minimize line length, fittings, elbow, etc and use of smooth surface pipe e.g. stainless steel may be considered.
Potential Surge Line
Steam supply line experience heat loss and condensation due to partially damaged insulation and extreme low ambient temperature. Flashing condensate with steam return to collection header mix with cold condensate. Both condition would results sudden steam collapse and lead to implosion. Steam implosion would generate severe movement of condensate in the collection header and severe vibration of header. Therefore proper maintenance of insulation is extremely important in keep steam line from transient surge. Besides, provide sufficient steam trap to eliminate condensate from steam line.
Long pipeline transferring incompressible fluid e.g. LNG rundown line, produce water injection line, etc potentially experience transient surge (water hammer) in the event of closure of shutdown valve. Transient surge analysis shall be conducted during design phase to ensure surge is avoided. Slower closure of shutdown valve is one of the key component in minimizing surge in long pipe line. Non-slam check valve on the pump discharge may also assist in minimizing surge in long pipeline with pump. Surge suppression system may be considered in the event surge is unavoidable. One shall take note that provision of pressure relief valve may not help to eliminating surge due to slow response time of PRV.
Pressure Relief Valve Inlet & Outlet
May consider discussion and recommendation in :
Control Valve & Restriction Orifice
Flow Induced Vibration (FIV) and Acoustic Induced Vibration (AIV) may be studied to identify location of piping which potentially experience high risk of low frequency and high frequency vibration. Minimizing small bore connection may be considered e.g. provision connection with more than 2 inches, avoid using connection smaller than 2 inches. For small bore connection, may consider brazing and extra support to strengthen the connection and avoid pipe cracking.
Anti-cavitation trim could be considered for control valve potentially experience cavitation. Similarly provision of multiple restriction orifice (RO) in series or multi-ported RO may be considered if cavitation occurs in RO.
Related Topic
- Process Critical Line
- Control Valve Cavitation Damage and Solutions
- Problems and Measures for Condensate Recycle Control Valve
- FAQ Related to Control Valves
- Useful Documents Related to Control Valve
- FREE & Reliable Control Valve Sizing Software
- Anti-surge Control (ASC) or Capacity Control (CC) Valve in Vertical Upward Run ?
- Combine Anti-surge control (ASC) & Capacity Control (CC) Functions ?
No comments:
Post a Comment